Comments on: Has Europe Failed to Integrate Muslims? /region/europe/has-europe-failed-to-integrate-muslims-02488/ Fact-based, well-reasoned perspectives from around the world Sat, 25 Apr 2015 02:19:37 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 By: mhy129 /region/europe/has-europe-failed-to-integrate-muslims-02488/#comment-32833 Sat, 25 Apr 2015 02:19:37 +0000 http://www.fairobserver.com/?p=47594#comment-32833 It is not Europe’s responsibility to ‘integrate’ Muslims. It is the Muslims’ responsibility to ‘integrate’ to European culture

]]>
By: Zarina Bhatia /region/europe/has-europe-failed-to-integrate-muslims-02488/#comment-32046 Mon, 19 Jan 2015 23:44:32 +0000 http://www.fairobserver.com/?p=47594#comment-32046 Professor Tahir Abbass writes an admirable article on this subject. Indeed the image British Muslims give out is of alienation generally speaking, talking of majority of Muslims living in the western world. First of all they are far from an amalgamation of a single entity; they are made up of a variety of sub-groups from different backgrouds, countries of origin, of faith groups, ideology, with cultural norms even speaking different languages. But above all they portray a traditional image by the way they groups identify themselves via their observance of dress codes, as an example. Their obviously recognisable image makes them visible. Women many of them wear a head scarf, men grow beards/moustache or wear what is called Salwar Kameez in areas where they are concentrated. Each communal group adheres to what its heritage might be.

One should not forget that this social image gives vibes to western countries as if Muslims remain aloof, and do not want to integrate with the host society. They may not assimilate but give an impression of not wanting to come half way and merge. I have deliberately generalised for ALL Muslims! This is far from the case as I have already clarified they are a pluralistic society and not a single entity.

In conclusion, there are other communities like the Jews, Hindus, Sikhs but the Government in Britain today has taken upon itself to target the Muslim leaders of numerous Mosques asking their members to explain how they regard themselves as a part of British Society, or don’t they? What efforts are made to prove that British culture is part of theirs too! In my opinion, this is a very divisive step taken in the wrong direction of alienating them further.

In case of a minority of Shia Ismaili Muslims, they have not just outwardly but also internally adapted assets such as western education, taken up various careers, professions or business enterprises. Thus they have ‘merged’ and amalgamated themselves with the host society. They have succeeded in retaining their practice of faith, culture, language, dietary norms but have made ‘friends’ with the local people. Most of them have acquired very high level of education and are now part of a Professional class of Citizens living in various European and North American countries. H H Aga Khan IV their hereditary Imam, in spiritual and worldly communal sense has always emphasised and guided them for generations on hand, to identify and adapt themselves with the people in countries of their abode. Ismailis are scattered over some 25 countries in many continents of the world. However, their adaptability is remarkable. Perhaps, other Muslim communities could take their example, regard them as a role model of this pace-making community. That will minimise Muslims being targeted as the ‘bad apples’ and ridiculed for their faith. What The west is doing is causing insult and aggravation by ridiculing their faith, in the name of ‘freedom’ that really amounts to license making not only these communities but their supreme religious leader namely Prophet Muhammad as an object of caricature pouring fuel to the fire of hatred and abuse in the name of ‘humour’.

]]>
By: Denise Chaplin /region/europe/has-europe-failed-to-integrate-muslims-02488/#comment-32044 Mon, 19 Jan 2015 10:14:35 +0000 http://www.fairobserver.com/?p=47594#comment-32044 ‘Various countries project on the “other” what they most detest about themselves. The French ban on niqabs (face veil) or the Swiss banning of minarets reveals more about how these nations are possibly running out of ideas, combined with a great degree of self-loathing.’
I think you have missed an important issue regarding the the clash of cultures on the Niqab. In the west facial expression has always been a significant part of inter-personal communication for the majority of people. Prior to the niqab, people also used face coverings to enable them to enact crimes or scams and not be recognised.

]]>