Whatās behind the Gaza protests in Paris and the rise of anti-Semitism?
Public Service Announcement: āBeing āPro-Palestinianā is not the same as calling for violence against Israel or Jewish people.ā This seems self-evident. However, many Palestinian supporters seem to feel that it is perfectly acceptable to use such civilized gems as āHitler was rightā and āJews to the ovenāĀ to express their sentiments. Do you really think screaming āDeath to the Jewsā (āMort aux Juifsā) conveys the supposed message of your Gaza demonstrations in Paris? My French is limited, but I know the word for āJewā sounds nothing like any word related to Israel.
State and Religion
I wish that the conflation of anti-Jewish sentiment and anti-ZionismĀ was an accident. If that were so, people could be made to realize and adjust behavior. But the real answer is that anti-Zionism is largely being used as an easy cover for anti-Jewish sentiment. Itās happening around the world, but letās talk about Paris because I live there. I donāt speak for Parisian Jewry, but only for myself in the capacity as an American Jew who is engaged with Judaism culturally.
Before I moved, I assured friends who voiced concerns about the anti-Jewish sentiment in France that there is a strict divide between state and religion. Technically, itās equally as frowned upon to wear a Star of David necklace as a cross in public schools here. No need to worry. Well, now Iām learning my lesson, as Iāve been encouraged by Jewish leadership here to not wear any jewellery that would identify me as a Jew, and to avoid speaking on the phone in public about Jewish topics.
Some will think this advice stems from paranoia. Well, when there is the distinct possibility of being targeted with tear gas, pepper spray, a taser or anĀ Ā just because you are a Jew, I think youād be a little jittery too. Those attacks on Jews occurred well-ahead ofĀ Operation Protective EdgeĀ in Gaza; and they are prevalent enough to be noted as aĀ consistent streamĀ of disturbing anti-Semitic acts by the French National Bureau of Vigilance against anti-Semitism (BNVCA). In the words ofĀ : āCriticizing Israel is not anti-Semitic, and saying so is vile. But singling out Israel for opprobrium and international sanction ā out of all proportion to any other party in the Middle East ā is anti-Semitic, and not saying so is dishonest.ā
I challengeĀ ³Ł°ł³Ü±šĢżpro-Palestinian supporters, those who do not conflate the issue with anti-Semitism: Arenāt you ticked off by those using your cause as nothing more than a guise to excuse their own hatred of Jews?
A French acquaintance told me not to worry because I donāt look Jewish ā what the hell does it even mean? But this advice flags two issues for me. First, what about the Jews who do look Jewish or wear traditional garb? And what if I want to use Yiddish words when I call my mother from the park? Second, regardless of how I look, I do live within Jewish Paris to some extent, which happens to not be far from where anti-Jewish violence in the name of anti-Zionism has taken place ā I frequent a liberal synagogue, I have a favorite falafel place in the Jewish Quarter. As such, I have felt my personal security threatened in ways I have never felt in any other country ā and Iāve been to and lived in a good few, includingĀ BelarusĢż²¹²Ō»åĢżSouth Africa.
French Prime Minister Manuel VallsĀ Ā the use of anti-Zionist rhetoric as a cover-up of anti-Semitic opinions. Foreign ministers from Germany, France and Italy have issued a jointĀ Ā condemning the rise in anti-Semitic protests and violence, and vowed to combat hostility against Jewish people. In my opinion, the government is standing up for the Jews in France, but the scary thing is that it doesnāt seem to matter to those who continue to conflate anti-Jewish sentiment and anti-Zionism. I would imagine that law-abiding French citizens were disturbed by the fact that a prohibitedĀ Ā was able to take place at all; a frightening signal of weakness and powerlessness by the state.
I suppose, what do I expect with the resurgence of nationalism, theĀ Ā winning parliamentary elections, and the popularity of a comedian like DieudonnĆ©? A recentĀ Ā suggested France has the highest percentage of residents (37%) who are openly anti-Semitic. Furthermore,Ā Ā claims: ā[H]atred for Israel and for Jews has become a major component of the identity of French of an Arab or African background; it is the cement of the second generation.ā Of course this doesnāt apply across the board. But to those to whom it applies, certainly they have the option to get positives from their culture, so why instead define themselves by hate and violence toward āthe otherā?
What Can Be Done?
Iāve had wonderful moments over the years helping to foster an understanding of the difference betweenĀ “³±š·É²õĢż²¹²Ō»åĢżIsrael. But in the current context of hate in Paris, while axes are literally swinging, I donāt quite feel up to the task.
Okay, have your own opinions about the conflation of anti-Jewish sentiment with anti-Zionism here in France, and in Germany, and in Austria ā¦ and in Canada. The length of that list and the places on it are chilling. It canāt be so hard to see that anti-Zionism can be legitimate (though I bet you can guess my stance), but conflating it with anti-Semitism is dangerous, hateful and perpetuates severe cycles of xenophobia, hatred and violence. Is using media likeĀ Ā to hunt down Jews and encourage violence in any way related to the pro-Palestinian cause?
I challengeĀ ³Ł°ł³Ü±šĢżpro-Palestinian supporters, those who do not conflate the issue with anti-Semitism: Arenāt you ticked off by those using your cause as nothing more than a guise to excuse their own hatred of Jews? I would think you are peeved ā at the very least ā that those who use protests to perpetuate anti-Jewish sentiment deflect attention from your cause. I challenge you to try to stop the conflation of anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism, if not for moral decency, and if not for my good and that of your Jewish neighbors, then at least for your own good.
“”ĢżĀ mentionedĀ in a 2012Ā Anti-Defamation League report indicated thatĀ significant portions of Europeans think āJews still talk too much about what happened to them in the Holocaust.ā There is a plaque 100 meters from my house on a school: āIn the memory of the students of this school who were deported ā¦ because they were born Jews.ā Well, maybe we should keep talking because it doesnāt seem like weāve learned very much since then.
There is the concept ofĀ Kol Yisrael Areāviim Zeh la Zeh (All Jews are responsible for one another) and it is a beautiful thing. But at the same time, I donāt want to witness a community that turns inward, feeling they canāt depend on police, but only the Jewish Defense League. I donāt want to consider the possibility of not depending on oneās fellow human when matters are serious; and they are serious! The Book of Genesis says allĀ humanity was created in the image of the Divine. In the words of Rabbi Philip Weintraub: āMay we find a way to see the humanity (and Divinity) in all people, paving the way for peace. Until such time when we can see the holiness in one another, let us at least find the humanity not to attack one another on the streets.āĀ Amen.
The views expressedĀ in this article are the authorās own and do not necessarily reflectĀ 51³Ō¹ĻāsĀ editorial policy.
/
Support 51³Ō¹Ļ
We rely on your support for our independence, diversity and quality.
For more than 10 years, 51³Ō¹Ļ has been free, fair and independent. No billionaire owns us, no advertisers control us. We are a reader-supported nonprofit. Unlike many other publications, we keep our content free for readers regardless of where they live or whether they can afford to pay. We have no paywalls and no ads.
In the post-truth era of fake news, echo chambers and filter bubbles, we publish a plurality of perspectives from around the world. Anyone can publish with us, but everyone goes through a rigorous editorial process. So, you get fact-checked, well-reasoned content instead of noise.
We publish 3,000+ voices from 90+ countries. We also conduct education and training programs
on subjects ranging from digital media and journalism to writing and critical thinking. This
doesnāt come cheap. Servers, editors, trainers and web developers cost
money.
Please consider supporting us on a regular basis as a recurring donor or a
sustaining member.
Will you support FOās journalism?
We rely on your support for our independence, diversity and quality.
Comment
After reading your article, I did some searches on Youtube, Google images, and few social media searches to support your extreme claim, but could not find any; at least of the magnitude you’ve implied. On FaceBook, I have seen many shared images of the Gaza massacre and various worldwide demonstrations with comments. While most comments were pro-Palestinian, there were few that went to the extent of relating Netanyahu to Hitler and Zionism to Nazism, which I, personally, can see the relationship. One comment, which I immediately replied to, was glorifying Hitler. My response was āhow could you or anyone exalt a child and woman murderer?ā
Lately, more and more Jews step out and demonstrate by writing or speaking, against Israelās occupation and aggression. The majority of people are becoming more and more aware and they know the distinct difference between Judaism and Zionism. Thus, protesting against Israelās terrorism does not automatically label the demonstrators as being anti-Jews or anti-Semitic, as you suggested.
Humanity definitely needs to step up on fighting genocide committed by the Zionists (not just anti-Semitism, as you declared). Yes, Palestinian women and children, who are also Semitic, are the victims of Israel Destructive Force. And, for humanityās sake, please state that, instead of whining about Israelās image. Oh, and please provide some evidence of your claim. Shalom!
While I sympathise with anyone who suffers discrimination or violence because of their ethnic/religious/whatever background, the article is utterly lacking in any historical context…
Should we condemn the conflation of anti-Zionism and anti-Jewish feeling? Of course. Any who is primarily responsible for this conflation? The state of Israel and its Western backers, who constantly describes it (and, indeed, demand that it be recognised) as “the Jewish State”, hail its Prime Minister as “the leader of the Jewish people”, run eroticised teenage booze-fests such as the “Birthright Programme” and frequently denounce any kind of criticism as “anti-Semitism”. In other words, it is primarily Israel itself which has actively worked towards this conflation, and so we should not be entirely surprised if its opponents sometimes suffer from the confusion it purposefully propagates.
Second: while we may say that anti-Jewishness (I shall not commit the logical fallacy of calling an Arab “anti-semitic) exists within Arab/Muslim populations as an EMPIRICAL FACT, this does nothing by way of CRITICAL ANALYSIS. It is, at best, a description – not an engagement. To the extent that it does exist within anti-Israel groups and, more specifically, Arab and Muslim population, this anti-Jewishness is so attenuated and removed from the historical – and specifically European phenomenon – of anti-Semitism that it is meaningless to use the same term to describe them.
Now, I am very happy to condemn anti-semitism or – a subtype of it – anti-Jewishness whenever I encounter it, but I refuse to do so unless I place it within its proper historical contest. Jews, despite some minor and (relative to the time) inconsequential discriminatory policies associated with dhimmitude, lived more or less peacefully in every major Arab city for hundreds of years. They were never more secure and prosperous than in Islamic Spain – and rarely more persecuted than after the Iberian reconquista by Christian armies. In so far as it exists, anti-Jewish sentiment among Arab and Muslim groups is a function of their opposition to Israel as a political entity, not vice versa.
That does not mean that the memes of European anti-semitism are not repeated or that I think that it is a good/productive/ethical way for people to express themselves, but this is absolutely NOT the same thing as European anti-semitism. Indeed, the very fact that Arab and Muslim people often rely on the repetition of these tropes is indicative of the DISCONTINUITY between European anti-semitism and anti-Jewishness as an expression of anti-Zionism – they have no significant indigenous canon on which to draw.
Unless and until the author engages in this discontinuity and attempts to understand WHY this superficially similar phenomenon is growing amongst Arab and Muslim populations, she will neither understand the “discrimination” directed against her, nor have any possibility of stopping it.
thanks for this article, I was really disturbed to read about your overall experience in paris and I pray for your safety.
you raise an important point about distinguishing between antisemitism and being against israeli policies and I’d like to hear more about the difference and how prevalent each is beyond what you say is a non-coincidental conflation with “anti-Zionism”. I am appalled, like you, with the instances of anti-semitism at some protests. There needs to be more effort to combat antisemitism in europe and it seems to me that the statistics you quote are mostly about antisemitism in Europe in general, not as primarily actions by “pro-Palestinians”. I’m concerned that by following the statistic that 37% of French people are openly anti-Semitic with what seems to be a quote that has no backing, and may be potentially racist, by Gil Mihaely, may be read as if you are insinuating that all Arabs/Africans in France are anti-Semitic and they are primarily behind antisemitism in europe, including the vile remarks in the ADL report- I am confident you don’t mean to make a racist and inflammatory remark though so it might be worth reflecting on. i also think it might be worth discussing the primary subject matter of the protests, and whether protesters are “pro-Palestinian” (which from what I gathered in the article only equates to being anti-Zionist) “anti-Jewish” or perhaps anti-genocide, as more than 1700 humans in Gaza have been killed, including over 250 children.
Humanity definitely needs to step up on fighting antisemitism, which on the whole is a phenomenon fairly independent of these “supporters”, as well as other xenophobias, and I hope that one day nobody has to worry about being Jewish, or Muslim, Black, etc., in Paris or anywhere else. Peace and justice on earth