51吃瓜

Iranian protesters may find that they got more than they bargained for if US President Donald Trump acts on his threat to intervene militarily in support of protesters. Mr. Trump鈥檚 threat may have emboldened Iranians to continue taking to the streets, assuming that the world鈥檚 most powerful leader has their back.

Many protesters and some US officials believe that US airstrikes would undermine the morale and cohesion of Iran鈥檚 security forces and spark defections and refusals to obey orders to crack down on the demonstrators. The risk is that striking regime targets could evolve into an attempt to topple the regime as advocated by and .

Trump administration officials have held preliminary discussions on what Iranian military targets the US could attack, possibly in a large-scale or targeting key military and security officials. The administration is also looking at , including boosting anti-government sources online, deploying cyber weapons against Iranian military and civilian sites, and imposing more sanctions on the regime.

For its part, Iran appears to be preparing for a potential US effort to topple the regime of 86-year-old Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, one of the world鈥檚 oldest and longest-serving leaders, who has been at the helm of the Islamic Republic for 35 of its 45 years.

Iran Open Data, a website that analyzes public Iranian government data, reports that the regime is the budgets of four security institutions 鈥� the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), the Intelligence Ministry, the judiciary and the national police 鈥� from $6.9 billion to $8.2 billion.

The US鈥� problem is that Iran is not Venezuela.

Why Iran is not Venezuela

In contrast to the US鈥� of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, which was supported by regional allies such as Argentina and Ecuador, the Greater Middle East, except for Israel, opposes US military intervention in Iran.

鈥漈he Venezuela operation has emboldened those who believe America can reshape the world through force alone. Meddling in Iran would likely prove this theory bankrupt,鈥� analyst Eldar Mamedov. Even so, Trump may see Venezuela as a , but only to a limited degree.

Mitigating in favor of a Venezuela approach is a belief among analysts that Mr. Khamenei no longer exercises full power in Iran. The analysts suggest that power is concentrated in an informal council that includes President Masoud Pezeshkian, Parliament Speaker Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf, Chief Justice Gholamhossein Mohseni Ejei, and representatives of the military and the IRGC.

This 鈥渄e facto collective leadership may pursue a 鈥榁enezuelan鈥� survival strategy: get rid of , reaching out to Trump, seeking sanctions relief, inviting US oil companies back into Iran, stabilizing the economy, and preserving the system,鈥� said Iran scholar Ali Afoneh in a series of postings on X.

鈥淚ran is no longer able to prevent foreign actors from boosting popular discontent at home鈥� Iran鈥檚 leaders were the first to acknowledge that they had survived the war thanks to their people. But it also became clear to them that a popular uprising was part of Israel鈥檚 war strategy, and this realization informs their view of the current protests,鈥� Iran scholar Vali Nasr, referring to last year鈥檚 12-day war with Israel.

Middle East scholar Mehran Kamrava added that the 鈥渨eakening of Iranian central authority is an Israeli objective.鈥� Even so, Israeli analysts believe that Mr. Mamedov鈥檚 cautionary note applies not only to the US but also to Israel.

In a posting on a Telegram page that some analysts link to the Israeli security establishment, Hananel Aviv, an unknown figure with no public record, warned that 鈥渋t is impossible to know or point out what the alternative to the Mullah regime is, and whether it will be good for Israel in the long run 鈥� If the regime is toppled directly by Israel and the alternative is bad for the West and the US, the world will make sure to blame Israel for it for generations to come.鈥�

The cautionary note didn鈥檛 prevent Ms. Aviv from echoing a widespread sentiment in Israel that their country should assist the protesters with media support, financial aid and arms. 鈥淔or decades, the Mullah regime took care to arm and build terror armies around us to destroy us 鈥� now it is Israel鈥檚 turn to return measure for measure and do a similar thing against the murderous Mullah regime,鈥� Ms. Aviv said.

鈥淭he Iranian people demonstrating in the streets are mostly waiting impatiently for external help; there are ways to do this, especially if the US will do the direct work or join Israel鈥檚 side behind the scenes,鈥� Ms. Aviv added.

The information war and the limits of Starlink

A Washington Post report suggested that US communications support for the protesters was complicated because a senior State Department official, Assistant Secretary for Consular Affairs Mora Namdar, had blocked funding for initiatives supporting unfettered information access in Iran at a time when it is most needed.

Iran late this week shut down the Internet in an unsuccessful effort to quell the protests and prevent the distribution of images of a potential brutal crackdown.

Ms. Namdar reportedly favors expanding Elon Musk鈥檚 , even though the devices needed to access the Internet via satellite cost up to $1,000 on the Iranian black market, a sum far beyond the reach of most ordinary Iranians on the streets due to their dire economic circumstances. US officials said they were looking at ways to smuggle Starlink terminals into Iran.

During anti-government protests in 2022 and 2023, the Biden administration opted not to deploy Starlink, fearing it would put at risk crucial smuggling routes used by the CIA and Israeli intelligence. 鈥淧erhaps this time, the benefit outweighs the cost,鈥� Washington Post columnist David Ignatius.

This week, the estimated tens of thousands of Iranians, many of them businesspeople who can communicate via Starlink, found that the government鈥檚 disruption of Global Positioning System (GPS) signals to counter drones was also interrupting their satellite connections. Starlink receivers use GPS signals to connect to a constellation of low-orbit satellites.

Regional fears of fragmentation and blowback

Most regional states, including the Gulf and Pakistan, fear that an intervention in a battle-hardened country armed with ballistic missiles would not produce a more submissive regime or allow for a smooth transition to a more cooperative regime.

Instead, they believe it could open the door to a violent disintegration of Iran, with ethnic minorities like the Kurds and the Baloch seeing an opportunity to declare independence, potentially with foreign backing, a throwback to past US and Israeli support.

鈥淚ran is a powder keg 鈥� Iran has as many, if not more, ethnic, religious, class, and regional cleavages as its Middle East neighbours. It is also loaded with small arms and young men trained during their mandatory military service to use them. It could easily explode or collapse,鈥� journalist Borzou Daragahi.

Separatism, insurgency and the risk of escalation

So far, the regime鈥檚 efforts to capitalize on fears that Iran could descend into civil war similar to Syria by warning against separatism and highlighting in recent days in state-aligned media, in Kurdish-majority regions in the west and among the Baloch in the southeast that are allegedly supported by Israel and the US have done little to stymie the protests.

Last month, Jaish al-Adl (the Army of Justice), a Pakistan-based group that traces its roots to Saudi-backed anti-Shiite groups in Iran with a history of attacking Iranian security forces, and other Baloch groups, created the Mobarizoun Popular Front to wage an against the Iranian regime.

The group said it an Iranian security official in Iran鈥檚 Sistan and Baluchistan Province on January 7. Earlier, it claimed to have security officials on December 10.

Jaish al-Adl has insisted in the past that it was not seeking Baloch secession from Iran. Instead, it wanted to 鈥� the regime of the guardianship of jurisconsult (Iran) to respect the demands of the Muslim Baloch and Sunni Muslim society alongside the other compatriots of our country.鈥�

Ansar al-Furqan, a Baloch group that did not join Mobarizoun, last month said it had Iranian security officials in Kerman Province. Iranian media put the number at .

Last week, three masked Lorians, one of whom brandished a weapon, to resist a regime crackdown. 鈥淚f you continue to suppress the people with guns and shotguns, the people of Luristan will no longer take to the streets empty-handed,鈥� the men said in a video statement. A minority close to the Kurds, Lors account for 6% of the Iranian population.

Media reports and analysts with close relations to various Middle Eastern nonstate actors said Iran, acting on information provided by Turkish intelligence, had recently of the Iraq-based Kurdistan Free Life Party (PJAK attempting to infiltrate Iran. A proponent of Kurdish autonomy in Iran, the PJAK has primarily launched hit-and-run attacks against Iranian security forces with alleged covert support of US and Israeli intelligence.

[ first published this piece.]

[ edited this piece.]

The views expressed in this article are the author鈥檚 own and do not necessarily reflect 51吃瓜鈥檚 editorial policy.